Last week Canadians were treated to another example of Conservative incompetence and ineptitude when Jim Flaherty announced the change in the taxation of income trusts. Despite promising less than a year ago not to do this, the Conservatives went ahead and announced that income trusts would be taxed, resulting in a 20% decline in the value of income trusts and a loss in value for investors of over $20 billion.
In any other developed country, someone who intentionally mislead investors in this way would be prosecuted by the relevant securities and exchange authorities. I can't think of any other developed nation where the government has had this kind of impact on the capital markets. It certainly makes Canada look like a third world country.
One can understand the government's concern about the increasing number of corporate conversions to income trusts and the resultant impact on government revenues. On the other hand, the government has recently announced that it appears to have an inexplicable increase in its tax revenues. Perhaps the reason for this is that investors have been paying tax on income trust distributions.
Even if one agrees that further conversions to income trusts are not in the best interests of Canadians, one shouldn't make changes in the tax regime in such a way that disrupts capital markets in such a major way. Normally, when such tax changes are implemented, they are implemented such that they only affect decisions going forward but don't result in retroactive clawbacks in value. If the government had simply enacted rules which would preclude any further trust conversions, it would not have had the same catastrophic impact on capital markets.
I sure hope that the Canadian voters punish these incompetent idiots in the next election.